Sunday, remembering, rethinking
There are events elsewhere, appalling, horrifying, unjust, cruel, vindictive… you can find them easily if you haven’t already, no need for links from here. There are responses too: angry, vindictive, triumphal, bigoted, hypocritical, despairing, determined, desperate, compassionate, consistent, supportive, inspiring.. Some are given headlines and airtime, others none or less so, some actively suppressed where they contradict or challenge the official narrative and view – these you have to look for. I may put a few links below, without preference, just because they are not invited to the top table of public media and political discourse.
I’ll just say two things here.
Killing civilians is wrong, any civilians, by anybody, on any side of a conflict. I condemn all killing of civilians. We have international laws on this – they only have meaning if we enforce them as best we can, not according to political expediency or view. I’m not in favour of war either, but that’s a longer discussion.
How events are presented and portrayed matters. How different aspects of a situation or set of events are reported matters. In news, as in visual art, the same elements of presentation shape the experience and perception of the content:
- Frame/context – choice of title, words, emphasis, placing in print, web, video/tv, radio, timing.
- Composition / juxtaposition – what order are events portrayed in? What follows what? How much space and time is given to each part? What effect do the preceding and subsequent elements have on the central content – how do colours change on different backgrounds?
- Tone – choice of language, pace, dramatic energy.
- Colour – alone and in contrast or harmony with neighbouring content.
- Questions you ask and the ones you don’t, which angle of view do you allow your audience?
So what? I am deeply troubled, disillusioned too, by the widespreading and mainstreaming of what can legitimately be described as propaganda in news reporting, even, no, especially in nations who like to present themselves as “free”, “democratic”, champions of liberty, etc. As if the internet had not been enough of a call to awaken and sharpen our thinking, this demands raising our game as adults and within our education system to ensure our children are not “illusioned” and “enchanted” by the propagandists; I think we must cultivate the skills of disillusion and disenchantment if we are to retain and regain any real freedom and autonomy of thought, belief, values, expression, association, affiliation, lifestyle.
Learning to see clearly and critically, as much metaphorically as visually, is becoming a vital tool for a free and autonomous citizen. Here are some of my thoughts for a citizen survival kit:
- question everything – except your sanity, your own right to exist and experience wellbeing.
- do not accept face value, check “what’s in the box?”, when you open it, read the manual.
- ask “who really benefits and how?” – follow the money.
- analyse those elements of framing, composition, language and so on, as above.
- resist cynicism about the fundamental nature of humanity – most people are ok, good even, given the chance.
- loving kindness and universal compassion are hard, sometimes, but always worth the effort of cultivation, even when you feel no progress. Anger, hatred, jealousy, aggression and selfish desire are poisons.
Time to take a walk away from screen and frames and feel the cold, still frosty air, the afternoon sunlight on the hills, the sounds of hungry birds in the bushes. It’s even time to leave this excellent mix, forwarded by Chris Reed: https://movingspaceart.uk/2023/11/12/chill-out-tunes/
Thank you for reading, comments and questions are welcome, (so is coffee if you find this valuable! https://www.buymeacoffee.com/surfsenseih 😀
Ah yes, some links as promised:
- https://www.youtube.com/@ADifferentBias
- https://www.youtube.com/@aljazeeraenglish
- https://www.youtube.com/@DoubleDownNews
- https://www.youtube.com/@NovaraMedia
- https://www.youtube.com/@ListenToTimesRadio
- https://www.youtube.com/@Channel4News
- https://www.youtube.com/@LBCOfficial
- https://www.youtube.com/@csis
- https://www.youtube.com/@GreshamCollege
and much more…. Keep well, remember to walk away from it all sometimes.